Monday, December 06, 2010

Asking the Right Questions from Birth Parents

This week I had three families contact me to let me know that because of the birth parent analysis they had received, they were able to take steps that resulted in their daughter's birth family being located. While I am sure these aren't the first or that last families that will have such a happy outcome, these three families all shared a common characteristic after locating the birth family: In each case, an interview was made with the birth family, and various questions were asked. But in all three cases, the wrong questions were asked. Wrong in the sense that the true reasons their daughter ended up in the orphanage lay undiscovered.

I am sure that some of this is a result of a general reluctance to push people that one has just met, combined with a fear that asking "insulting" questions might cause the birth family to retreat and perhaps refuse further contact. Having interviewed birth families ourselves, this essay is designed to aid a family that has located a birth family in gaining as much information as possible.

In nearly every birth parent finding that I have experienced myself, or that has been communicated to me by families that have been successful, the discovery resulted in a realization that the traditional understanding of the child's abandonment was wrong. In nearly every case, instead of the child being found at the gate of the hospital as was communicated through the adoption paperwork and finding ad, for example, it was discovered that she had in reality been picked up directly from the birth family by an orphanage employee or foster mother. This makes sense when one realizes that birth family searches are most successful when the chain of custody between the birth family and the orphanage is unbroken. If a child is truly abandoned with no witnesses, establishing contact with the birth family will be much more difficult, often impossible. Because a complete chain of custody by definition implies that the orphanage was less than completely honest, adoptive families must be extremely sensitive to how questions about their child's abandonment are asked.

The first realization adoptive families must have is that the first contact with the birth families will be the best opportunity to obtain the "ungarnished" story of their child's history. Word in China travels quickly, and if it is discovered that a birth family has been located, finders, orphanage personnel, etc., will almost certainly attempt to control the story. While some adoptive families may feel that a level of trust must first be earned before the "hard" questions can be asked, doing so allows for others to come in after-the-fact and convince the birth family to change the story or to hide pertinent information.

The most important thing to keep in mind is that the birth family rarely, if ever, knows the information provided by the orphanage. Thus, instead of asking "Why did you leave my daughter at the gates of the orphanage?" ask "Can you please explain to me how you decided to relinquish your daughter, and how that occurred?" Don't assume birth dates and finding dates are accurate. Ask the birth family, "Can you remember the exact date and time your daughter was born?" instead of "Was your daughter born on March 13, 2008?" In many cases, the adoptive family will want to determine the role of incentive programs in their child's abandonment. Instead of asking "Did anyone offer you money to turn your child into the orphanage?", ask "Did anyone give you 'Lucky Money' in thanks for allowing your daughter to be adopted into our family?" By using direct, yet non-accusatory, language, the birth family will not feel guilt or shame, and be much more likely to answer the questions truthfully. If you feel disapproval at a response you receive from the birth family, do your best to mask it. If the family, for example, tells you they relinquished your daughter so that they could try again for a boy, instead of responding by asking "Why did you feel a boy was more valuable or important than a girl?" say something such as "That must have been a hard decision. What factors were most important in helping you make that decision?" What I am trying to convey here (in words that can no doubt be improved upon) is to try and keep any judgments or assumptions out of your questions. "Don't lead the witness," in court parlance.

The environment for the interview is almost as important as the questions themselves. Often families will interview the birth family while officials are near, especially if those officials were the avenues through which the birth family was found. If at all possible, minimize any questioning while others are around, such as other children, neighbors, etc. Try to establish surroundings that will make the birth family feel comfortable and in control such as dinner in a quiet restaurant, or by having the conversation in a park. The residence of the birth family is also very conducive to an interview if the birth family can successfully be quarantined from outside listeners. Position yourself so that you can watch their face, look into their eyes, study their mannerisms. This will not only create an intimate atmosphere that will build trust, but also make the birth family less likely to say something false. In any interview, have a video recorder or mp3 player with plenty of capacity simply next to you on the table. Don't point the camera at the subject, but act like you are just setting it down to talk. This will allow you to record the conversation for later re-hearing, yet not create fear on the part of the birth parent at being recorded.

By knowing the circumstances of an orphanage -- the patterns, demographics, etc. -- coupled with a direct yet non-accusatory question set, an adoptive family can get behind the "corporate story line" and learn the true reasons their child was relinquished, what factors played the largest role in that decision, and how it was that the child made their way into the orphanage for adoption.

10 comments:

Jena Heath said...

Brian,
This is a really helpful post. Two questions:

Is there any point in having a third party, who is in China, try to interview the birth family once found? Or is that something you believe should be done by the adoptive parents themselves?

How much attempt to establish contact either with the finder or birth family should happen long-distance? And if you advice contact from the U.S. in what form? Letter? Phone call?

Thanks,
Jena
Austin

Research-China.Org said...

Jena:

I would discourage any attempts at making contact long-distance for the simple reason that it is very easy to be deceptive through a letter or even over the phone. I have found that finders are most cooperative when a non-Western individual is doing the interview, but that is not a hard and fast rule. Getting someone that knows the "lay of the land" (incentive programs, finding clusters, Family Planning, etc.) is a must, so that they can know the answers to expect even before they are asked. In that way the interviewer can press where it is obvious that more information is to be had.

Brian

mosusan2004 said...

Brian,

More and more, I'm thinking that many of our children were NOT left anonymously by the birth family (at the orphanage gate, in front of government buildings, etc.) as their paperwork states. I have heard it said that often a birth family, perhaps through a friend or relative, makes arrangements directly with the village committee, Family Planning, or Civil Affairs staff who act as the conduit to the orphanage. Cars and vans are used to transport the children as often the birth family, especially if rural farmers, would not own one.

If this is the case (what percentage of all supposed findings I couldn't even guess) then the result must be that many SWI Directors/Vice-Directors/bookkeepers (especially bookkeepers!) must know the identities of the children. Especially in cases where the "finder" is a government employee, I'm thinking that there's a strong possibility that the "finding" was not accidental...

What are your thoughts on this scenario and, if it is commonplace, how could a searching family best use this knowledge as it relates to their child "found at the gate"...??

Thanks,

Susan Morgan
mosusan2004@yahoo.com

Research-China.Org said...

Susan:

What you describe is often the case. Such connections are often the situation.

Brian

Anonymous said...

Brian,

How soon after your child comes into your family, should one search for their birthparents? I hear the repercussions for birthparents for relinquishing their child can be severe.
This is the major factor we have been holding off trying to locate birthparents for fear that they will be punished.

Research-China.Org said...

My recommendation is as soon as possible. Time does no favors for searching. If done correctly, there should be no repercussions for the birth family.

Brian

Von said...

It's pleasing that the truth of Chinese adoptions is coming to light at last.
As an adoptee I accept that time does not favour searching.However I strongly believe it is the adoptee's perogative to search or not and that adopters taking over that part of an adoptee's journey is disempowering.

Research-China.Org said...

I agree that an adoptee should be empowered to make the decision to search or not. However, waiting 15 or 20 years for the adoptee to begin searching will doom most searches to failure. That is why I believe adoptive parents should search, obtain the information, and preserve it for when the adoptee decides it is wanted. I discussed this in my article "What to Tell and When" (http://research-china.blogspot.com/2010/05/what-to-tell-and-when.html). I don't believe that the actual searching is empowering or disempowering, but rather the control of the information, which I agree should be left with the adoptee.

Brian

Anonymous said...

Brian, i guess we are one of the families who contacted you to tell you we have find the BP. But you are wrong, we know why my daughter ended in a SWI.
Sometimes is not just a matter of asking the right questions, but to win their trust.

Research-China.Org said...

Congratulations on a successful search! Winning trust is of course very important, but trust without good questions won't bring much success.

All the best!!

Brian